
Clear As Mud edited by Warren Payne
This book has been a long time in coming. For decades the field of Kentucky art pottery has been a mystery. Not only has it been a mystery to novices but also to seasoned antique dealers like myself. There is a handful of Kentucky potteries, but all have as many quirks and bends in their history as any Ohio or New England pottery does. And until this time there was no rhyme nor reason to the markings, glazes or shapes.
In an interview, author Warren Payne said “Kentucky has a long history of pottery-making . From the crocks and jugs of the 19th century river trade to the sophisticated vases of the 1920s Selden-Bybee line, the commonwealth has been up to its knees in clay. As with many Southern states, the concept of “art pottery,” a concept very hard to nail down even among scholars, came later than it did to some East Coast and Midwestern potteries. But Kentucky’s art pottery hewed closed to a simple folk-inspired template that in its best examples reminds one of archaic Mediterranean and Asian forms. And I mean “simple” in the sense that the Shaker aesthetic, a Federal house, a Blanchard spoon [Asa Blanchard was a silversmith from Lexington, Kentucky], a dry-stone fence, that these demonstrate a simplicity that is terribly sophisticated. However, much of the literature on American pottery is hung up on the concept of pottery as canvas, something to be painted on or ornamented once you come up with your base glazes. I find this concept to be very Victorian, grounded in the Aesthetic Movement, and essentially dated. I look at some pieces of Rookwood, for example, and I know they would never really look good in my home, which despite our love of the old has been influenced by over a hundred years of spare, modernist thought. Yet the most basic piece of Kentucky art pottery fits in as though it were made for the space, as would virtually any piece of ancient Asian pottery. There’s a lesson there – and an appreciation for what was created in Kentucky under very difficult conditions.”
This book is an excellent start to a wide and diverse category. I say start because, as well written and researched as this book is, I still have more questions. The nearly untouched topic of Kentucky art pottery has the potential to have a book devoted to each chapter featured here in this work, a worthy suggestion I think. It is lavishly illustrated with high quality color photographs on high quality paper. The photographs are worthy of framing in their own right. The chapters are broken down into various fields of interest. Each chapter is written by a collector or scholar, so it gives you a first hand view of the workings of a collectors / scholars mind. Chapter topics include but are not limited to: “Waco Pottery” by Larry G. Hackley,” Louisville Pottery Company (Cherokee) ” by Stephen J. Lee and my personal favorite “Kenton Hills Porcelains” by Nick & Marilyn Nicholson. A very helpful feature is a series of pages scattered through several chapters titled The Bottom Line that show the various marks on what ever pottery is being discussed in that particular chapter. Though the vast majority of illustrations is well-captioned, there are several pages on which the photographs are not captioned. The necessary information regarding these photos is contained in the body of work but a novice Kentucky art pottery dealer / collector might need things pointed out a little more clearly. This is a minor detail in a great ground- breaking work. The text, although written in a scholarly manner, is easily read and understood.
This soft backed book with 119 numbered pages is published by the Cane Ridge Publishing House in Paris, Kentucky, with an edition of only 1000 copies. The book retails for $30.00 and is available on eBay, Carmichael’s bookstores in Louisville and at the book’s Web site:
http://www.caneridgepublishinghouse.com/clearasmud.htmlThere are plans are for it to be sold through Borders bookstores, book/gift shops and in such venues as The Louisville Stoneware Co., the Kentucky Museum of Art & Craft and Speed Art Museum in Louisville, KY, the Log House/Boone Tavern shop in Berea and at Lexington outlets.
This is sure to be a desirable and collectible book in the future. An enjoyable and educating read. This book is highly recommended for all lovers of Kentucky pottery and Kentucky decorative arts.
Remember Knowledge Is Power, So Arm Yourself